Starting 7/18/24, 6:30:00 pm: Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!

A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder Cast List

TCR Production

Janelle and I were overwhelmed by the amount of talent at this audition. Turning away some of the area’s best and most beloved performers – in addition to new folks who came on strong or even killed it – is not fun. With only 11 positions to fill, Gentleman’s Guide is a pretty taut puzzle. We weighed voice type, tone, how far a head start you’d have on dialects, how your voices would fit together, facility with multiple roles (both for the the D’Ysquiths and the ensemble), and a host of other factors. If you have concerns about your audition or desire feedback, please email me at

Personally, I am very honored each and every one of you auditioned, including many new people, some fantastic Coralville and Iowa City folks, some lovely people who we haven’t seen at auditions for a while, and many others we admire and adore. You almost made me want to quick switch musicals to something that would allow us to cast many more of you. Come back again please. Kinky Boots and Mamma Mia auditions will be here before you know it! ~Angie

A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder Cast

Jordan Arnold – Sibella Hallward

Nadine Borngraeber – Miss Shingle

Mic Evans – Montague “Monty” Navarro

Jessica Dunnik – Woman 3: Mourner; Sibella’s maid; Tourist; Ancestral Portrait; Miss Evangeline Barley; Bridesmaid; Miss Hayes; Tailor; Hilda (Servant); Flower Girl.

Erin Lauer – Phoebe D’Ysquith

Matthew McGrane – Man 2: Mourner; Tourist; Ancestral Portrait; 1st Clerk; Skater; Tailor; Groomsman; Pub Owner; Mr. Cross; 2nd Newsboy; Weight Lifter; 1st Actor; Lord Asquith’s Physician; Ancestral Bust; Mr. Waters (Servant); Chief Inspector Pinckney.

Aaron Murphy – The D’Ysquith Family

Beth Nelsen – Woman 2: Mourner; Tourist; Ancestral Portrait; Skater; Bridesmaid; Mrs. Hetherington; 4th Newsboy; Tailor; Lady Eugenia D’Ysquith; Flower Girl.

Kara Ramirez – Woman 1: Mourner; Tour Guide; Ancestral Portrait; Skater; Bridesmaid; Pub Owner’s Wife; Mrs. Pebworth; Phoebe’s Maid; 3rd Newsboy; Tailor; Selina Chard (Servant); Flower Girl.

Alex Young – Man 3: Mourner; Tourist; Ancestral Portrait; Skater; Tailor; Groomsman; Pub Patron; Henry’s Employee; Mr. Goodsall; 2nd Actor; Alfred Gorby (Butler); Lord High Steward (voiceover); Magistrate.

John Zbanek-Hill – Man 1: Mourner; Tourist; Ancestral Portrait; 2nd Clerk; Skater; Tailor; Groomsman; Tom Copley; Dr. Brownlee; 1st Newsboy; Weight Lifter; 3rd Actor; Ancestral Bust; Walter (Servant); Dr. Pettibone (Medical Examiner); Prison Guard.

Congrats to our cast! Information about scripts and measurements to come. The first meeting will be on December 4th at 6:30 p.m.